Blogspot Sued for Dead Blogger's Content

By Eric Goldman

Davis v. Google, 09 CH 15753 (Cook County Ct. complaint filed April 9, 2009)

Venkat sent a very interesting lawsuit this morning that raises some complex policy issues. The complaint alleges that Sean Healy created a blog at unknowncolumn.blogspot.com and posted defamatory content about speedskater Shani Davis' mom, Cherie Davis.
[I believe the post in question is at http://unknowncolumn.blogspot.com/2006/02/memo-to-cherie-davis.html -- I'm not going to link to it, but it did show up as my first search result for "Cherie Davis"].

The complaint further alleges that Healy is now deceased, so he can no longer remove the content on Cherie's demand, and he did not have a "probate estate" to take over his blog. As a result, Cherie feels like she has nowhere to turn to clean up the alleged defamation, so she is suing Google's Blogspot for a takedown injunction.

On the face of it, the lawsuit is clearly preempted by 47 USC 230, and Google ought to get a quick and unambiguous win. However, there are some lurking policy issues about dealing with online content posted by now-deceased individuals:
* Presumably the content and the account passed through Healy's estate. Even if there was no "probate estate," whatever that means, there is still a legal protocol for succession of Healy's assets--including the copyrights in his blog. So someone now owns Healy's blog, and it should be possible to determine who that is.

* Even if the legal rights have been allocated, taking control over a deceased accountholder's account is not always easy. The last time I recall this issue being discussed, it was in the context of taking control over deceased military personnel's email accounts. Online providers have different policies about how to deal with this--and for good reason, as too loose a policy could enable account hijacking, plus there may be concerns about the deceased accountholder's privacy. I wonder what Blogspot's policy is. This issue won't come up often, but it will definitely come up again.

* If Cherie can't sue Healy's estate, instead of suing Blogspot, I wonder if Cherie could seek a declaratory judgment that the content is defamatory. I would be shocked if Blogspot wouldn't honor a declaratory judgment in Cherie's favor, and it's not exactly like Healy would contest it.
SOURCE

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Day to Bare Our Souls - and Find Ourselves

Image
The lack of ritual makes Yom Kippur's power elusive for many. How do we make meaning from the holiest but most daunting day on the Jewish calendar? By Rahel Musleah My friend Anat dreads Yom Kippur. Fasting makes her grumpy, and by morning she already has a headache. Nor does the synagogue setting encourage atonement, meditation or self-reflection for her. As a nonobservant Jew, she says, "my relationship with God is such that I can't even begin to atone for what I do—nor do I want to. What's left are my relationships with other people, and I try to take care of those on a daily basis." Still, says Anat, the strong aura of the day, redolent of childhood and community, draws her to spend Yom Kippur in the synagogue. "If this is a holy day I'll treat it as such and stand with others around me. Every year I think about the millions of people who are doing exactly what I am doing on Yom Kippur. It doesn't matter how secular I am. This is my commitme
Read more

'Fat People Aren't Unstable' -- For This We Needed a Study?

Image
First let me say I don't like being fat. Yes, I diet and yes, to the degree my disability (unrelated to my weight) allows me - I do exercise. A while back someone posted really malicious things about my weight, my character and even my disability online. Even throwing in a very twisted, backward and upside-down version of what really occurred between us. To wit (edited for foul language): You used the internet to track him down after 30 years, which wasn’t too hard because he’s a published writer. You got him to agree to meet up with you. When he did meet up with you, to his horror, he saw that his ex-girlfriend from college had ballooned into a 275 lb fat pig with poor hygiene and he didn’t want to bang you. He politely excused himself by saying he couldn’t do this to his wife. You then began stalking him and his family, driving by his house, sending letters to anyone with whom you thought you could slander his good name. His poor wife was left with no choice but to report you
Read more

Miriam's Cup

Image
Several new Passover seder rituals are being adopted by Jewish familes to honor the role of Miriam, Moses's sister and the Prophetess in the Exodus, and to highlight the contributions of women to Jewish culture, both past and present. A second cup, called Miriam's Cup, is being added to the Passover dinner table along with Elijah's Cup. Miriam's Cup is filled with water and symbolizes the miracle of Miriam's well, which sustained the Israelites during their long journey in the desert.
Read more